| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14-May-1995 | John Burridge | Manchester City | England | 03-Dec-1951 | 43(163) |
| 13-May-2007 | Alec Chamberlain | Watford | England | 20-Jun-1964 | 42(327) |
| 06-May-2000 | Steve Ogrizovic | Coventry City | England | 12-Sep-1957 | 42(237) |
| 10-Nov-2013 | Brad Friedel | Tottenham Hotspur | United States | 18-May-1971 | 42(177) |
| 14-Mar-2015 | Mark Schwarzer | Leicester City | Australia | 06-Oct-1972 | 42(159) |
| 12-Mar-2000 | Neville Southall | Bradford City | Wales | 16-Sep-1958 | 41(178) |
| 01-Jan-2005 | Kevin Poole | Bolton Wanderers | England | 21-Jul-1963 | 41(165) |
| 10-Apr-2011 | Jens Lehmann | Arsenal | Germany | 10-Nov-1969 | 41(151) |
| 30-Dec-2006 | Teddy Sheringham | West Ham United | England | 02-Apr-1966 | 40(272) |
| 22-May-2011 | Edwin van der Sar | Manchester United | Netherlands | 29-Oct-1970 | 40(205) |
| 06-May-2014 | Ryan Giggs | Manchester United | Wales | 29-Nov-1973 | 40(158) |
| 18-Sep-2016 | Shay Given | Stoke City | Republic of Ireland | 20-Apr-1976 | 40(151) |
| 10-Jan-2004 | David Seaman | Manchester City | England | 19-Sep-1963 | 40(113) |
| 21-Oct-2013 | Kevin Phillips | Crystal Palace | England | 25-Jul-1973 | 40(88) |
| 03-May-1997 | Gordon Strachan | Coventry City | Scotland | 09-Feb-1957 | 40(83) |
| 15-Dec-2021 | Willy Caballero | Southampton | Argentina | 28-Sep-1981 | 40(78) |
| 24-May-2015 | Steve Harper | Hull City | England | 14-Mar-1975 | 40(71) |
| 01-Jan-1997 | Bryan Robson | Middlesbrough | England | 11-Jan-1957 | 39(356) |
| 20-Feb-1999 | Dave Beasant | Nottingham Forest | England | 20-Mar-1959 | 39(338) |
| 11-Nov-2000 | John Lukic | Arsenal | England | 11-Dec-1960 | 39(336) |
| 11-Feb-2015 | Jussi Jaaskelainen | West Ham United | Finland | 19-Apr-1975 | 39(299) |
| 01-May-2010 | David James | Portsmouth | England | 01-Aug-1970 | 39(274) |
| 26-Dec-2008 | Dean Windass | Hull City | England | 01-Apr-1969 | 39(270) |
| 19-Jan-2019 | Julian Speroni | Crystal Palace | Argentina | 18-May-1979 | 39(247) |
| 05-May-1996 | Ray Wilkins | Queens Park Rangers | England | 14-Sep-1956 | 39(234) |
| 11-May-1997 | Les Sealey | West Ham United | England | 29-Sep-1957 | 39(225) |
| 23-Apr-2024 | Thiago Silva | Chelsea | Brazil | 22-Sep-1984 | 39(214) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).